A Muslim nonprofit has filed a religious liberties lawsuit against the Town of Oyster Bay for denying an application to expand and upgrade a Bethpage mosque.
The federal lawsuit, filed Friday in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York by Muslims on Long Island (MOLI) and two congregants, claims MOLI and Oyster Bay’s Muslim community have been trying to upgrade and expand their Masjid Al-Baqi mosque for more than six years, but have been opposed by the town of and members of its Planning Advisory Board “at every turn, enduring multiple layers of bureaucratic resistance,” according to a statement from the group.

The lawsuit maintains that the mosque project, which would have created a new two-story building to replace the two one-story buildings on Central Avenue that the mosque currently operates out of, has been opposed by town officials and some community members. The plaintiffs claim that the town even amended its parking ordinance in 2022 to require significantly more parking from new places of worship, which it was aware that MOLI would not be able to provide on its 1.3-acre property.
The lawsuit, which additionally names five members of Oyster Bay’s Planning Advisory Board as defendants, also claims that the proposed project has endured multiple layers of bureaucratic resistance as well as community pushback, citing Islamophobic posts on social media such as: “Does anybody remember that there were two towers in Manhattan or did people forget and now we’re asked to put a place like this in downtown [B]ethpage really?!”
The lawsuit also calls out Nassau County Legis. Rose Walker for leading the opposition against the mosque project, which it claims contributed to its application denial from the Nassau County Planning Commission last summer.
When asked to respond, Walker said, “Masjid Al-Baqi mosque has been a wonderful part of the community and excellent neighbors. The expansion plan, however, does not account for the significant need for additional parking and impacts to traffic on the surrounding roadways. I am hopeful that Masjid Al-Baqi will be amenable to working with the local municipality to reach a compromise or to identify an alternate location in the Bethpage community that would allow for continued growth.”
MOLI and its co-plaintiffs, mosque congregants Imran Makda and Moeen Qureshi, are represented on a pro bono basis by a Patterson Belknap team led by partner Muhammad Faridi, a Muslim-American and president of the New York City Bar Association.
“This case is about standing up against bigotry and protecting the fundamental rights of all Americans, regardless of their faith,” Faridi said via emailed statement. “For over six years, the Muslim community in Bethpage has endured an unprecedented campaign of discrimination and resistance, all because they sought to upgrade their modest house of worship to better serve their community. We are confident that the court will uphold the principles of religious liberty and equal protection enshrined in our Constitution. The right to worship freely and without prejudice is not just a cornerstone of our laws—it is a core promise of America. This lawsuit seeks to ensure that this promise is kept for all people, including Muslims in Bethpage.”
Oyster Bay Town Attorney Frank Scalera responded by saying, “While we do not comment on the specifics of pending litigation, these claims are baseless, unjustified and attempt to divide the community. Our town’s policies are applied equally and reflect fairness for all, regardless of faith. The town takes great pride in its proven dedication to diversity and inclusiveness.”
MOLI contends that the modernization and expansion project is needed because the mosque lacks adequate facilities for religious education, ritual washing, and religious and community events. The mosque hosts weeknight religious classes for its youth and because it lacks classrooms or adequate storage for tables and chairs, it currently educates its children on the floor of its main prayer area.
The plaintiffs are suing under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, the First and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution, the New York State Constitution and Article 78 of the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules, according to the statement. Under these protections, they said, a mosque cannot be prevented from expanding its inadequate facilities just because it is a mosque.
“As members of this community, we’ve only ever wanted a place where we can pray, learn, and gather in peace,” Imran Makda, a plaintiff and board member of the mosque, said. “It’s heartbreaking to see our efforts met with such resistance and discrimination. This is not just about a mosque—it’s about being treated fairly and with dignity as neighbors and citizens. We believe in the promise of America, where everyone has the right to worship freely, and we hope this lawsuit will ensure that promise is upheld for all of us.”















































































