The Amityville Horror House: A Haunted History

A Tragic Beginning

The Amityville Horror House, located at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, New York, is one of the most infamous haunted houses in American history. Its dark past began on November 13, 1974.

The DeFeo Murders: A Tragic Event

The Massacre

On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. committed a heinous crime, shooting and killing six members of his family at 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville:

• Ronald DeFeo Sr. (father, 42)
• Louise DeFeo (mother, 42)
• Dawn DeFeo (sister, 18)
• Allison DeFeo (sister, 13)
• Marc DeFeo (brother, 12)
• John DeFeo (brother, 9)

The Investigation

Police discovered the bodies at approximately 3:15 a.m. on November 13, 1974. Ronald DeFeo Jr. reported the crime, claiming a mysterious gunman had entered the house.

Arrest and Trial

However, investigators soon discovered evidence pointing to DeFeo Jr. as the perpetrator:

• Gunpowder residue on his clothing
• Inconsistencies in his alibi
• Motive: DeFeo Jr. stood to gain a substantial inheritance

DeFeo Jr. was arrested on November 15, 1974, and later convicted of six counts of second-degree murder.

Sentencing

On December 4, 1975, DeFeo Jr. received six concurrent life sentences, ensuring he would spend the rest of his life in prison.

Imprisonment and Death

DeFeo Jr. spent 37 years in prison before his death on March 12, 2021, at the age of 69.

Motivations and Controversies

Theories surrounding DeFeo Jr.’s motivations include:

• Financial gain
• Family conflicts
• Mental health issues

Some experts argue that DeFeo Jr.’s actions were premeditated, while others suggest he was driven by impulse.

The Aftermath

The community was shocked and horrified by the brutal killings. The house, once a peaceful family home, became a site of unspeakable tragedy.

In December 1975, George and Kathy Lutz purchased the house for $80,000, unaware of the horrors that awaited them.

The Lutz Family’s Descent into Horror

The Lutz family’s brief tenure in the Amityville Horror House was marked by unrelenting fear and chaos.

Paranormal Experiences

The Lutz family claimed to have experienced:

• Ghostly Apparitions: Unsettling encounters with unseen entities
• Mysterious Moving Objects: Furniture and objects moving on their own
• Unexplained Noises and Voices: Strange sounds and disembodied voices
• Green Slime on Walls: Unexplained substance appearing on walls
• Doors Opening/Closing by Themselves: Uncontrollable door movements

Their ordeal lasted only 28 days, from December 18, 1975, to January 14, 1976.

Abandoning the House

The Lutz family’s decision to leave was sudden and drastic, leaving behind most of their belongings.

George Lutz’s Account

In his book, “On the Trail of the Amityville Horror,” George Lutz described:

• Experiencing unexplained noises and movements
• Feeling an intense, unsettling energy
• Witnessing ghostly apparitions

Kathy Lutz reported:

• Feeling a presence in the house
• Hearing disembodied voices
• Seeing moving objects
• Experiencing unexplained cold spots
• Sensing a malevolent energy

The Children’s Experiences

The Lutz children, Daniel and Christopher, also reported strange occurrences:

• Seeing ghostly apparitions
• Hearing strange noises
• Feeling an intense fear

The Final Straw

On January 14, 1976, George Lutz woke up to find:

• A pair of glowing eyes staring at him
• A voice whispering “Get out”

This experience marked the final straw for the Lutz family, and they abandoned the house, leaving behind most of their belongings.

Abandoning the House

The Lutz family’s decision to leave was sudden and drastic. They claimed the house had become uninhabitable due to the intense paranormal activity.

A Haunted Legacy

The Amityville Horror House’s notorious reputation spread rapidly, captivating the nation’s attention.

Paranormal Investigations

Ed and Lorraine Warren, renowned paranormal investigators, examined the house in 1976. Their findings further solidified the house’s haunted reputation.

The Amityville Horror House has been featured in numerous films, books, and documentaries:

• “The Amityville Horror” (1979) – starring James Brolin and Margot Kidder
• Remake (2005) – starring Ryan Reynolds and Melissa George
• Documentaries: “The Real Amityville Horror” (2005), “Amityville: The Awakening” (2017)
• Books: Jay Anson’s “The Amityville Horror” (1977), “The Amityville Horror Part II” (1982)

Theories and Explanations

Several theories attempt to explain the paranormal activity surrounding the Amityville Horror House:

The Native American Connection

Some believe the house was built on sacred Native American land, sparking a curse.

The DeFeo Family’s Dark Past

Others suggest Ronald DeFeo Jr.’s motivations for the murders were rooted in family dynamics and mental health issues.

Investigations and Evidence

Numerous investigations have attempted to uncover evidence of paranormal activity at the Amityville Horror House.

Ed and Lorraine Warren’s Investigation

The Warrens collected audio recordings of unexplained noises and voices.

The Amityville Horror Case Files

These files, compiled by paranormal investigator Rick Moran, detail:

• Witness statements
• Photographic evidence
• Audio recordings

Physical Evidence

Several pieces of physical evidence have been reported:

• Unexplained cold spots
• Moving objects
• Ghostly apparitions

Skeptical Perspectives

Some experts argue that the Amityville Horror House’s reputation is exaggerated or fabricated.

Debunking Claims

Skeptics point to:

• Lack of concrete evidence
• Contradictions in the Lutz family’s story
• Questionable motivations

Alternative Explanations

Experts propose alternative explanations:

• Folie à famille (shared family delusion)
• Mass hysteria
• Environmental factors (e.g., mold, structural issues)

Personal Accounts and Testimonies

Those who have visited or lived in the house share chilling experiences.

George Lutz’s Later Years

George Lutz, in interviews, maintained:

• The experiences were genuine
• The house had a profound impact on his life

Eyewitness Accounts

Several eyewitnesses have come forward with accounts of paranormal activity:

• Unexplained noises
• Ghostly apparitions
• Unsettling feelings

Legacy and Cultural Impact

____________________________________________________

The Amityville Horror House has:

• Inspired countless adaptations and interpretations
• Become a cultural phenomenon
• Solidified its place in American folklore

Influence on Popular Culture

The Amityville Horror House has influenced:

• Horror movies and literature
• Paranormal investigations
• Popular culture’s perception of haunted houses

Conclusion

____________________________________________________

The Amityville Horror House remains an enigmatic and terrifying figure in American history. While debates surrounding its legitimacy continue, one thing is certain:

The Amityville Horror House has etched itself into the collective consciousness, forever changing the way we perceive horror and the paranormal.

Bibliography

1. “The Amityville Horror” by Jay Anson (Amazon)
2. “The Amityville Horror Case Files” by Rick Moran (Goodreads)
3. “The Amityville Horror: A Study in Horror” by Stephen Kaplan (Google Books)
4. “The Amityville Horror: The True Story” by Hans Holzer (Barnes & Noble)
5. “On the Trail of the Amityville Horror” by George Lutz (Archive.org)

Further Reading

1. “The Amityville Horror Part II” by John G. Jones (Amazon)
2. “The Amityville Curse” by Hans Holzer (Goodreads)
3. “Amityville: The Awakening” by Alexandra A. Luria (Google Books)
4. “The Real Amityville Horror” by Ed Warren (Barnes & Noble)

Documentaries and Films

1. “The Amityville Horror” (1979) (IMDb)
2. “The Amityville Horror” (2005) (IMDb)
3. “The Real Amityville Horror” (2005) (Documentary Storm)
4. “Amityville: The Awakening” (2017) (IMDb)

Online Resources

1. The Amityville Horror Official Website (www.amityvillehorror.com)
2. Amityville Historical Society (www.amityvillehistoricalsociety.org)
3. Paranormal Investigation Association (www.paranormalinvestigation.org)

Books on Related Topics

1. “The Haunting of Hill House” by Shirley Jackson (Amazon)
2. “The Shining” by Stephen King (Amazon)
3. “Ghost Hunters: William James and the Search for Scientific Proof of Life Beyond the Grave” by Deborah Blum (Amazon)