Review: “The Mouse Trap” (2024) – Slasher Comedy FAIL

In the ever-evolving landscape of horror, the slasher genre has been a staple, drawing fans with its blend of suspense, gore, and, at times, dark humor. Enter “The Mouse Trap,” a 2024 horror slasher that attempts to walk this fine line but ends up stumbling over its own ambitions. Directed by Jamie Bailey and penned by Simon Phillips, this Canadian film tries to inject fresh life into the genre by using a public domain icon, Mickey Mouse, as the centerpiece of its terror.

Plot Synopsis

“The Mouse Trap” centers on Alex (Sophie McIntosh), who finds her 21st birthday celebration at the arcade where she works turning into a nightmare. Her friends’ surprise party is crashed by a masked killer inspired by the “Steamboat Willie” version of Mickey Mouse. As the night unfolds, they’re locked in, with no mobile phones and a killer who has a bizarre aversion to strobing lights. What starts as a quirky horror setup quickly devolves into a chaotic, often nonsensical chase to survive the night.

Film Analysis

The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

Unintentional Humor

One of the film’s few saving graces is its unintentional humor. Scenes that are meant to convey horror or tension instead come off as comedic due to awkward dialogue and bizarre plot developments. While some might find this endearing, it’s clear that the film’s attempts at blending horror and comedy miss the mark more often than they hit. The serious moments that turn laughable indicate a disparity between the filmmakers’ intentions and the final product’s impact.

Pacing and Structure

The structure of “The Mouse Trap” is a convoluted mess, with a narrative that jumps between past and present, confusing viewers more than engaging them. The film takes an excruciatingly long time to get to the action, with Mickey doing more skulking and waving than actual slashing. When the kills do come, they lack the inventiveness or shock value that fans of the genre typically look for.

Dialogue and Character Development

The dialogue in “The Mouse Trap” is cumbersome, with characters often discussing what it would be like to be in a ’90s slasher film—a meta approach that falls flat due to the lackluster script. The characters themselves are thinly sketched, making it difficult for the audience to care about their fates. This lack of depth is a critical flaw in a genre that, while not always known for deep character studies, still requires some level of investment in the characters’ survival.

Acting and Performances

The acting is a mixed bag, with Sophie McIntosh’s Alex and Nick Biskupek’s Detective Marsh standing out in an otherwise mediocre ensemble. The overuse of ADR (additional dialogue recording) suggests significant post-production changes, adding to the disjointed feel of the performances.

Visuals and Setting

The arcade setting could have been a vibrant backdrop for the horror, echoing classics like “The Last Starfighter” or even “Tron” in its neon-lit potential. However, “The Mouse Trap” presents a strangely dark and uninviting arcade that lacks the nostalgic charm one might expect. The absence of classic arcade games mentioned in the reviews (like Daytona and Time Crisis 2) is a missed opportunity to anchor the film more firmly in its setting.

Directing and Production

Jamie Bailey’s direction seems unsure, with a film that feels like it’s been pulled in multiple directions. The use of a Mickey Mouse-like figure could have been a clever nod to public domain usage, but it comes off as a gimmicky afterthought rather than a fully realized concept. The film’s heavy-handed disclaimer about its non-affiliation with Disney is an awkward start that sets a jarring tone for what follows.

The Kills and Horror Elements

For a slasher film, “The Mouse Trap” is surprisingly tame in its approach to horror. The kills are mostly off-screen or lacking in creativity, undermining the slasher element that is fundamental to the genre. The killer’s fear of strobing lights is an interesting quirk but is underutilized in creating suspense or innovative showdowns.

Overall Thoughts

“The Mouse Trap” is an example of a film that tries to be too many things at once and ends up being none of them effectively. Its attempt to mix horror, comedy, and a meta-commentary on the genre is ambitious but poorly executed. The film might find a niche audience among those who appreciate “so bad it’s good” cinema, but for most horror fans, it will be a disappointing addition to the slasher canon.

Rating: 2/5

Pros:

• Unintentionally funny moments.
• Some stand-out performances in an otherwise weak cast.

Cons:

• Confusing narrative structure.
• Lackluster kills and horror elements.
• Poor character development and dialogue.
• Mixed acting and overuse of ADR.

Conclusion

“The Mouse Trap” attempts to join the ranks of horror films that cleverly use public domain characters to craft unique stories but falls dramatically short. Instead of a sharp, witty take on the genre, it delivers a muddled mix of tones and styles that fail to gel into a cohesive narrative.

The film’s heavy reliance on unintentional humor might make it a future cult classic for viewers who revel in the absurdity and flaws of low-budget horror movies. However, for those seeking genuine scares, suspense, or a clever plot, “The Mouse Trap” is a misstep that doesn’t quite know what it wants to be.

In a landscape where horror can range from high-concept psychological frights to gore-filled spectacles, there’s a place for every type of horror fan. Unfortunately, “The Mouse Trap” struggles to find its place. It’s neither a competent slasher film nor a successful comedy, and its lack of engaging characters and inventive horror set-pieces leaves it in a limbo of mediocrity.

For fans of the genre looking for a night of horror and thrills, the advice would be to look elsewhere. While “The Mouse Trap” might serve as an interesting case study in how not to blend horror and comedy, it’s not a film that satisfies the cravings of true horror aficionados.

Final Verdict

In the end, “The Mouse Trap” is a film that will be remembered more for its missed opportunities than for its achievements. The idea of turning Mickey Mouse into a slasher villain is intriguing and could have opened the door to a new wave of horror films that play with our collective nostalgia in dark and twisted ways. Unfortunately, the execution here leaves much to be desired.

Overall Rating: 2/5 ghosts – For the few laughs (intentional or not) and the novelty of its premise. However, it’s a film that ultimately fails to deliver the kind of cohesive, engaging, and thrilling experience that makes a slasher film memorable.

Recommendations for Viewers:

• If you’re curious about the film, watch it with tempered expectations and perhaps a good sense of humor.
• For a better blend of horror and comedy, consider classics like “Scream” or “Shaun of the Dead.”

“The Mouse Trap” is a lesson in how difficult it can be to balance humor and horror, and a reminder that not every attempt to subvert genre norms will be successful. While it might find its audience among those who appreciate its campy approach, it’s not a film that will stand the test of time in the crowded field of horror.

So, what did you think of “The Mouse Trap”? Did it capture the fun of the slasher genre, or did it leave you wishing for a quicker escape from its clutches? Share your thoughts and let’s discuss this odd entry into the world of horror.